(Kan)Ye or Nay?

Is he in…or not?

Is he for real about Jesus…or is he pulling a fast one?

Is he actually saved…or does he just think he is?

Is he really trying to serve God…or is he just desperate for good publicity?

Is he a baby believer clumsily trying to find his footing…or is he a sleeper agent of the devil looking to make a mockery of the church?

Are all the people who believe he’s truly been converted just gullible, non-discerning idiots?

Are all the people who are skeptical of him just non-compassionate, judgmental haters?

Just so you know, all of these questions are rhetorical. I doubt I could answer them to anyone’s satisfaction. So I won’t waste my time trying. But I have to be honest…I’m really frustrated with how some of my Christian brothers and sisters are reacting to this situation.

It’s as if some are unwilling to even entertain the slightest possibility that Jesus may have actually saved Kanye West.

I understand the need for a healthy level of skepticism in this situation, particularly given Kanye’s “track record”…pun intended. It wouldn’t be very wise to just absentmindedly take his word for it when he says that he’s given his life to Jesus.

But why are some of us so QUICK to dismiss him?

Is the God we serve incapable of saving a man like Kanye? Is God unwilling to sully His holy hands with the muck of Kanye’s past sins? Is God simply not interested in redeeming a guy who indulged in idolatry and called himself “Yeezus” at one point?

I think most believers would emphatically answer ‘NO’. And yet, I believe that’s precisely the message being communicated when so many of us immediately write Kanye off.

And even worse, I get the sense that many are actively looking for that one scandalous headline, that one wayward quote from an interview, that one misstep on Kanye’s part that will prove what they “knew” all along.

What does that say about us? I think it says that we have a bad case of selective amnesia…and an even worse case of subtle hypocrisy.

It’s one thing to be discerning and watch for fruit like Jesus tells us to. It’s another thing to cut down the tree before the fruit even has a chance to grow.

Is Kanye truly saved? I don’t know for certain.

But I would rather patiently hope for the best than loudly assume the worst.


  1. I would rather be wrong believing the best of somebody than be right in believing the worst….his truth is for he and God to sort out, we were told to love another, as in everybody. My only concern is for the people who may now follow him in a way that is to be allotted only to Jesus.

  2. love this post

    I have had some questions about the way the evangelical community has reacted to Kanye vs Trump. Both have stated they are Christians but one is accepted no questions asked, the other has their faith questioned all the time. It seems funny that the one who renounces their past ways is treated as opportunist while the other who seems to have no problem with what they have done and continues to live life in a highly questionable way, is embraced.

    I wondered “out loud” in my post (A Modern Day Parable) if it is the desperate desire to find a leader who will bring back Christian values that causes the blindness to his unrepentant, ungodly behaviour? Because he does not hold public office Kanye is not given the same pass as he has no power to change the laws of the land (maybe in 2024) Or, as disturbing as it would be, is it possible that we are more likely to question a black person’s motives over a white person?

    I am white from a different country so I don’t know – I am uncomfortable saying these things as it can lead to everything being seen through the lens of racism and I don’t think we want to go there or every action and assertion no matter how innocent can be labeled as racist. Still, I have to wonder why Trump is the evangelical golden boy and Kanye untrusted.

    1. Wow Dave…trust me, you’re not the only one who has wondered about this. And don’t let your discomfort stop you from saying the hard things. It is SO needed.

Leave a Reply